Here's a disc that's bound to get good reviews. For starters, Leon Fleisher's story is so compelling, his manual renaissance so inspiring, that many people will be won over before they even open the jewel case. "Imagine that," one person might say to another person, "his first concerto recording in over forty years. Isn't that amazing?" Talk of this sort usually leads to several copies being purchased as gifts, to be accompanied by notes describing in some cursory fashion the evils of focal dystonia and the wonders of, amongst other things, Botox. The recipients of these gifts, impressed by the story, will have a listen to hear what a newly invigorated right hand sounds like and will come away touched, not by the novelty of Fleisher's situation, but rather by the quality of his playing.
The disc includes three concertos, No. 12 in A Major K.414, No.7 in F Major for three pianos (in this case two, the second played by Fleisher's wife, Katherine Jacobson-Fleisher) K.242 a.k.a. the "Lodron Concerto," and No. 23 in A Major K.488, each of which sees Fleisher accompanied by the Kammerorchester Stuttgart.
I should say right off the bat that the Lodron Concerto is not my favourite piece of music. I've always found it formulaic and boring, particularly its second and third movements, and I'm sorry to say that the rendition on this disc is no exception. The playing is delightful, particularly the bravura on display at the start of the first movement and at the end of the development, but there's only so much that can be done with the piece. The Fleishers wring as much sonic diversity out of the concerto as they can, but it's a losing battle.
The same can absolutely not be said about No. 12, which showcases Fleisher's talents and style in high relief. There's something so lovely and relaxed about his playing. The music he produces just seems to spread and spread, producing a nice full sound that's extremely well suited to orchestral playing. His touch is a bit heavier than it used to be, and at 80 his trills have lost some of their airy speed, but the result is a pleasant surprise: the weight gives the performance a more terrestrial feel, and the music benefits enormously. In the first movement, for example, the music comes across more playful than humorous, more jolly than giddy. Fleisher's playing in the second movement is charged with wonderful character, and is full of intermingling emotions that at certain times seem to be at loggerheads but then quickly rearrange themselves to become co-conspirators. This movement is a great favourite of mine because the playing is so exposed. It can easily catch out many lesser musicians, but it can also provide more capable ones with a terrific platform to show their stuff, which is exactly what Fleisher does. His control over the music is outstanding, particularly with regard to transitions and pacing, and he repeatedly conjures the most wonderful largo phrasing. I didn't notice an off-balance moment throughout the entire piece.
Ditto for No. 23, which is a far more substantial composition. Fleisher's in no hurry, and allows us to join him in savouring some remarkable melody lines. What's more, he plays like a conductor, always keeping an ear on the swivel to make sure he knows what the orchestra is up to. The result is that he actually plays with the band, which seems to be an increasingly rare feat these days. This is especially true in the capricious first movement and in the intimate, almost sonata-like adagio second. The finale is all grace and low-grade explosives. A few of Fleisher's runs were a bit uneven, but who really cares. The personality of the playing is convincing enough to convert glitches to idiosyncrasies, and as we all know, idiosyncrasies, whether in people or in music, are where the good stuff's found.
The album, Leon Fleisher: Mozart Piano Concertos, went on sale on March 31st.