It's been a hectic few weeks for me, and I'm looking forward to a few days of R&R before I head off to Switzerland for a spell. Before I go, though, I figured I should do some housekeeping at NT. For starters, I'd like to disagree with Hilary Finch of the Times for what must be the thousandth time. Her review of Juan Diego Flórez's recent concert at the Barbican was ominously venomous, and I suspect she might be harboring a JDF bias of her own, albeit one in opposition to the prism of adoration employed by his fans. Many of us enjoy supporting an underdog, but every once in a while that impulse gets corrupted into a compulsion to topple giants. The concert was hardly Flórez's greatest effort, owing largely to a frog in the singer's throat, but that's how it goes with live music, and a fair assessment of the performance needs to consider obvious physical factors. For instance, the 9 high Cs in Donizetti's Amici miei -- a tune that Jessica Duchen and I both think sounds better in French -- are less affected by phlegm than the subtle piano lines in Rossini's Pace non trovo, which require unencumbered vocal suppleness. Accordingly, saying that "Flórez uses one single gear, one expressive mode, one universally
applied vocal colour," and basing the statement on a handicapped performance is patently dismissive. Finch gave the concert three stars out of five; I agree with the score, but not with the reasoning. Flórez will be back in London this fall to sing Matilde di Shabran at Covent Garden, and I'd encourage the lady from the Times to reserve a seat and her judgment.
On another note, I've spent the last hour listening to Boston Secession's latest cd, Surprised by Beauty: Minimalism in Choral Music, and find myself impressed by the effort. It doesn't take much to get me to admit that I'm not Minimalism's greatest fan, particularly in its serial or formulaic guises, but then again most of my experiences with the genre have been instrumental. What sounds to me cold and mechanical coming from instruments can sound more fallible and inspiring when issuing from a person, or people. While some of the album's thirteen songs may be broadly considered "difficult music," most of the tunes are pretty user friendly. Take for instance Gavin Bryar's And so ended Kant's travelling in this world, which is a beautiful piece that kept making me think of the lush harmonies in Fauré's Requiem. And then there's Arvo Pärt's The Beatitudes, which is a long-standing favourite of mine, and I was happy to hear it done justice. One of my surprise favourites was William Duckworth's Hebrew Children, a song that embodies the vocal factor mentioned above and feels like a combination of ecumenical liturgies. I found it to be utterly hypnotic. Less so for Ruth Lomon's Transport and Duckworth's War Department, but hey, you can't win 'em all, and there's no accounting for some people's tastes.
