The last time I heard Mozart's G minor symphony was at the Royal Festival Hall in June, when it sprang from a wicked little cell phone possessed of a fine sense of mischief. Entertaining as the experience was, it wasn't nearly so fulfilling as hearing the Academy of St. Martin-in-the-Fields play it for real at the Barbican last night. They're a tight band, and got the balance just right, particularly in the second and fourth movements, both of which shimmered with life as a show of gratitude. Masterful as the orchestra's playing was, however, it couldn't save the other item on the menu, Beethoven's Violin Concerto, played by the soon-to-be-ex-wunderkinder, Chloë Hanslip.
Ol' Op. 61 gets saddled up all the time, and I've observed it enduring its fair share of meddling, but I've never known so saccharine a rendition. There's something to be said for the ability to produce clarion tones -- which Hanslip can certainly do -- but when those notes get stretched like taffy, and hover silvery and a-twinkle in the stage lights, well, a dollop of intervention is necessary. While the first movement wasn't too badly affected in this regard, the second was hard hit, and would have been very well suited to the soundtrack of a Georgian costume piece. (A good one, though -- maybe Northanger Abbey.) Hanslip's gorgeous notes were a pleasure to contemplate independent of the score, but when heard in context they were far from musical. The piece's transitions were thrown off kilter, and the music on the whole came dangerous close to bathos. In fact, there were a couple of moments when I caught myself rolling my eyes as she played, which is something I'd have formerly declared impossible for Beethoven's V.C. The most glaring break in flow came at the segue from the second movement to the third, which if played properly produces a real event, but in this instance offered a few stutter steps before shuffling off in a workaday dance. It was disappointing, and quite frankly a bit surprising given Hanslip's abilities and schooling. If anyone should know how to play a Concerto full of hazardous corners it's her.



