Till, We Meet Again
Till Fellner and his magic fingers paid a visit to the Wigmore Hall last night to regale an enthusiastic audience with a foursome of Beethoven piano sonatas, the three works of Op. 10 and the famously freewheeling Hammerklavier. Mr. Fellner's a regular at the Wigmore and has become a local favourite for reasons that are easy to deduce. His sound is an unusual blend of elegance and heft, light as a spectre at times and, while never quite heavy, weighty and full-figured at others. Above all, at least for me, is his control of voicing and pace. He's able to marshal separate lines with terrific musicality, and can somehow make overlapping legato phrases sound clear and articulated instead of gloopy and impressionistic. These attributes are clearly on display in his Bach recordings and were liberally employed last night as well.
The evening began with a solid and perfectly safe rendition of Op. 10 No. 1 that had the feel of a warm up and all the dramatic tension of one too. For all his strengths, Fellner seems to still struggle at times to keep the line taught, so to speak. Things will be humming along nicely there on the knife edge when all of a sudden the strain is interrupted and we listeners are left with a hand full of un-bitten nails. It took me a little while to put my finger on what deflates certain moments, but I think I've figured it out. Whereas some pianists play staccato notes in extremely short, very secco manner, Fellner lingers on them for just a fraction of a second longer than most. This naturally produces a more legato staccato, and while it works brilliantly at times -- as in the final movement of Op. 10 No. 2 -- it also has a tendency to de-fang movements that possess a more stabbing personality. Even the Largo e mesto second movement of Op. 10 No. 3, dirgeful and broad as it may be, needs some piercing articulation to build the tension necessary to deliver us successfully to the wonderful sense of rebirth that we fill as we hear the first phrase of the third movement. It has to be one of the greatest effects in the entire repertoire, but the setting needs to be just right in order to get the full treatment, and I'm sorry to say that Mr. Fellner missed it by just a hair.
Fortunately, there was far more to enjoy in the performance than there was to disregard, and there were several instances of really breathtaking playing. The fourth movement of Op. 10 No. 3 was simply remarkable and was played with such control over individual phrases and with such an ear to the overarching line that I was positive it would be the highlight of the evening. I was wrong. That distinction went to Fellner's performance of the Hammerklavier, which was right on the mark on the whole, and where the last movement was concerned, absolutely first rate.
There's good news for those of you who weren't in the audience last night. The Beeb recorded the concert and plans on airing it at 7:00 pm on July 15th. Set your stereos to record.